Tag Archives: us them mentality

Reading Alexander Hamilton

Alexander Hamilton, an eighteenth century refugee to America from the West Indies, served as a young aide to General George Washington in the Revolutionary War. He served his adopted country again as President Washington’s first treasury secretary.

After reading Alexander Hamilton, by Ron Chernow, I realize how much we owe Hamilton for the financial structure he laid out in our nation’s beginning years. However, I was most struck by the nation’s titanic political battles during those years and our continuing struggles into our present day.

Indeed, we have fought over our nation’s directions and choices for its entire existence. We fought Great Britain to gain our political freedom, yet many of our founding fathers owned slaves with no freedom. Great Britain abolished slavery in most of her empire a few decades after the American Revolution, while its former colony, having won the struggle for independence, would not give up slavery for almost another century.

We have struggled over racism and women’s rights. We struggled over the power of monied interests to bribe politicians. We have struggled for a civil service uninfluenced by those interests. We have struggled over the use of our military power and our influence in the world.

Our discovery of the internet and social media have increased ways to share news and ideas, but the struggles evidenced in our tweets mirror the old battles between selfishness and service. Demagogues take advantage of those frightened by changes, as they always have, encouraging an us/them mentality.

Overcoming the never ending dangers to the republic bequeathed to us by Washington and Hamilton is a constant struggle. We will always struggle; that’s the price of choice by fallible humans.

The issue is whether we can disagree without hatred. It depends as much as anything else on our ability to sympathize with those with whom we disagree. As long as we respect each other, we can work for solutions.

Circle the Wagons

During times of great change, we are tempted to circle the wagons against any perceived threats to our traditional ways of life, spooked even by unsubstantiated rumors.

Thomas Albert Howard reports on “The Dangers of Hindu Nationalism” in First Things (March, 2016). He reports on increased attacks against Christians and Muslims in India in the past few years, as Hindu nationalism revives. In 1948, Mahatma Gandhi himself was assassinated by a Hindu nationalist.

But a frightening, changing world encourages belief groups to grow more inward and arrogant, from young Muslims who embrace ISIS to Christians who burn the Quran to Americans threatened by a seeming loss of political faith in American institutions.

No belief system, liberal or conservative, is immune. Words that caricature simple faith as hogwash can fuel the flames as much as bigoted nationalism.

Just as a more radical Hindu nationalism encourages a clinging to the ancient Indian caste system, so any movement based in fear encourages its own “caste” systems, that is, encourages an us/them mentality.

The times call for a particular kind of bravery to hold strong personal beliefs yet not denigrate those who hold different ones.