Tag Archives: All the Light We Cannot See

City Street Lights and Brexit

Our small town plans to replace the city’s street lamps with bulbs that last longer and use less electricity. One type of light is being considered, but residents in some cities with these lights have criticized the emission from the bulbs as “too harsh.” Thus, one such light was installed on a corner for residents to examine its effects and decide if they want them all over town.

Since we’re little more than six square blocks, most residents can easily walk over after dark and check it out. They are then invited to email the mayor with their observations. A yes or no decision suits this kind of situation.

Not so with Brexit, the vote by the British to leave the European Union. The European Union was formed over several decades following World War II. The goal was the formation of a closer union to avoid more war and brutality between the nations of Europe, especially between Germany and France. Anybody who has read The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah or All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr understands the tragedies of those wars.

Few deny that the European Union has made mistakes, including, some say, the creation of a single currency before adequate institutions were built to manage it. Others cite mistakes in handling the mass migration into Europe from the Middle East, Africa, and Asia.

Nevertheless, critics of the Brexit referendum complain about a complex question being put to a yes or no vote. Such a contest pushes citizens into warring camps, leading to sensational claims and unfounded accusations. It may have contributed to the death of a member of the British parliament, perhaps by a mentally deranged man, too easily angered.

Issues like immigration or job growth differ from decisions about street lights. The answer normally is not a simple solution, but perhaps a compromise between several ideas. Labeling and name calling those with whom you disagree is best avoided. The dream of one right answer is a delusion.